So I was reading “The Tank Lords” by David Drake, a collection of short stories about his Hammer’s Slammers mercenary group. They use tanks, to put it mildly, as their main source of force. It’s funny, though. These were published in the ‘80’s. He has an appendix detailing some stuff about his universe, and some of his principles.
He gave a history of tanks, which is a combo of real history bleeding into his history of the future. It all read true at first, the guy’s a veteran of Viet-Nam who served in a Cavalry regiment, and he studied his history. It all came apart when this tid-bit of old 70’s defense wisdom came through.
“Individual infantrymen of 1970 carried missiles whose warheads burned through the armor of any tank. Slightly larger missiles ranged kilometers to blast with pinpoint accuracy vehicles costing a thousand times as much. Similar weaponry was mounted on helicopters which skimmed battlefields in the nape of the earth, protected by terrain irregularities. At the last instant the birds could pop up to rip tanks with their missiles. The future of armored vehicles looked bleak and brief.”
And then, he drifts into science-fiction land where the tank had been revived by fusion reactors, air-cushion propulsion, and superhard iridium hulls. It just found it funny that he was positing this future when at the time his book was published, modern technology had already put the tank back up as the primary tour de force of many armies.
Depleted uranium and composite armor replaced steel. No infantryman or helicopter could destroy and Abrams or Challenger with a missile. Hell, the tank’s own main guns could barely destroy them. Just look up some tank stories from Desert Storm, and you’d think your reading science-fiction, hell, FANTASY!!!, when you discover how much punishment the new behemoths could take.
In addition, tanks have become magnificent street fighters, whereas before they were highly vulnerable in cities. Technology fixed that too with advanced sensors and panoramic cameras giving the crew a view to the outside, letting them see that RPG team lining up a shot in the house around the corner – not to mention closer coordination with infantryman.
We’ve seen many instances where the real world has trumped the ideas of science-fiction, meaning writers of the genre need to get ever more creative and even more in touch with the realities of technology around them. Otherwise, they wind up looking a bit foolish. David Drake’s oversight is a small one, and I still enjoy his old writing, but let it be a message to those authors of the field – be smarter.
Science Fiction isn’t Fantasy.
The Struggling Writer; or, More Writing Math
22 hours ago